🐶🐱 How to Choose a Pet Sitter for Your New Puppy or Kitten
Bringing home a new puppy or kitten is one of the most exciting—and heart-melting—moments in any pet lover's life. But along with the cuddles and cuteness comes a lot of responsibility. And when you need to step away for work, travel, or emergencies, you can’t just leave your fur baby with anyone. New puppies and kittens are like toddlers: they need constant supervision, gentle handling, socialization, training, and a ton of love.
That’s where a qualified pet sitter can become your best ally.
Whether you're stepping out for a few hours or taking a weekend trip, finding the right pet sitter for your new addition is crucial for their safety, development, and well-being. In this blog, we'll walk you through everything you need to know to find the perfect sitter for your puppy or kitten—someone who will treat your young pet with as much care as you do.
🍼 Why Puppies and Kittens Need Specialized Pet Sitting
Unlike adult pets, puppies and kittens:
- Can’t hold their bladder or bowel movements for long
- Are still learning social and household boundaries
- May chew, bite, or scratch as part of their development
- Need frequent feeding and hydration
- Can easily get into dangerous situations (chewing cords, swallowing small objects, etc.)
- Require a structured routine to grow into well-behaved adults
In other words, they’re adorable little chaos machines—and leaving them unsupervised can lead to accidents, injuries, or emotional distress.
That’s why the pet sitter you choose should be trained, attentive, and patient, with experience handling young animals.
🧭 Step-by-Step: How to Choose the Right Sitter for Your Puppy or Kitten
1. ✍️ Understand Your Pet’s Needs
Before you even start searching, take stock of your pet’s:
- Age and breed
- Feeding schedule
- Potty training stage
- Temperament (shy, bold, energetic, etc.)
- Behavioral tendencies (biting, meowing, barking)
- Special needs (vaccinations, medical care, etc.)
This will help you communicate clearly with potential sitters and filter out those who aren’t the right fit.
2. 🔍 Where to Look for Qualified Sitters
Try these platforms and options when searching:
- Rover– Filter for sitters with “puppy/kitten experience”
- Care.com– Post a listing with specific age-based requirements
- Local vet clinics and shelters– Staff often moonlight as pet sitters
- Facebook pet care groups or neighborhood apps– Word-of-mouth recommendations
- Professional pet sitting agencies– Many train staff in handling young animals
💡 Tip: Ask other new pet parents for referrals—they’re likely facing the same challenges.
3. 🧑⚕️ Prioritize Sitters With Young Pet Experience
Ask directly whether they’ve worked with:
- Teething or chewing puppies
- Litter-training kittens
- Basic training routines (sit, no biting, leash introduction)
- Handling early vaccinations or vet visits
- Feeding and toileting schedules for young pets
Not every sitter has the energy or know-how to keep up with a rambunctious pup or a sneaky kitten. Find someone who understands the developmental stage your pet is in.
4. 🗣 Interview with the Right Questions
A good interview reveals how a sitter thinks and reacts in different scenarios. Here are sample questions to ask:
General:
- How long have you been pet sitting?
- Do you have experience with young puppies or kittens?
Puppy/Kitten-Specific:
- How do you handle a pet that bites or scratches?
- Are you familiar with crate training or leash training?
- How often will you let the puppy out for bathroom breaks?
- What would you do if the kitten tried to climb somewhere unsafe?
Safety & Training:
- Do you know how to pet-proof a space?
- Can you reinforce training commands we’ve started?
Their answers should reflect patience, attentiveness, and safety awareness.
5. 🏡 Do a Trial Visit
Arrange a short visit or trial run to observe how your pet and the sitter interact. During this session, notice:
- Does your puppy/kitten seem at ease or afraid?
- Is the sitter gentle but firm?
- Do they set boundaries in a calm, consistent way?
- Are they actively engaging with your pet—playing, cuddling, redirecting biting or rough play?
It’s okay if your pet is shy at first, but the sitter should know how to earn trust slowly and respectfully.
6. 📝 Leave Clear Instructions
Even the most experienced sitter needs your guidance. Leave a written or digital care guide that includes:
- Feeding times, food type, and portion sizes
- Water refills (kittens especially dehydrate quickly)
- Potty break schedule (for puppies) or litter habits (for kittens)
- Rules of the house (no jumping, scratching, etc.)
- Emergency contact info (your vet, nearest 24-hour clinic)
- Crate or bedtime routine
- Toys and games they enjoy
Consistency helps young pets feel secure, especially when you're not there.
7. 📸 Stay Connected with Updates
Ask your sitter to:
- Send you daily (or even hourly) photo or video updates
- Report on potty, eating, and play habits
- Let you know if any unusual behavior occurs (vomiting, whining, hiding, etc.)
This keeps you informed and reassured, and helps you track your pet’s adjustment.
8. 💼 Ask for Pet Sitter Certifications
Look for sitters with training in:
- Pet first aid and CPR
- Basic puppy or kitten training
- Fear-Free certification(gentle and anxiety-reducing handling)
- Experience at vet clinics, rescues, or doggy daycares
Certifications aren’t mandatory, but they show that the sitter is serious and committed.
9. 🐾 Know When to Hire an In-Home Sitter
For young pets, especially under 4 months old, it’s best to hire someone to come to your home rather than boarding them elsewhere. Familiar surroundings reduce:
- Stress and separation anxiety
- Risk of infection (important for unvaccinated puppies/kittens)
- Disruption of early training routines
An in-home sitter can also help continue leash training, crate training, and socialization.
10. 💕 Look for Patience and Passion
At the end of the day, trust your gut. The best sitter for your new pet will be someone who:
- Genuinely loves animals
- Treats your pet like family
- Is calm, gentle, and respectful
- Has the energy and patience for a young pet’s mischief
🌟 Real-Life Story: Luna and Max
When a new Golden Retriever puppy named Luna came into Max’s home, his family panicked before their planned weekend trip. Boarding her wasn’t an option, and she was still teething and unvaccinated.
They found Sarah, a sitter with experience in young dog care. She visited four times a day, reinforced crate training, and sent regular photos. Luna thrived in her care and didn’t miss a beat in her potty training progress.
Sometimes, the right sitter doesn’t just help—they make your puppy’s early development even better.
🐕🐈 Final Thoughts: Your Baby Deserves the Best
Leaving a young pet in someone else's care can feel overwhelming—but with the right sitter, it becomes a partnership. Someone who can nurture your puppy or kitten in your absence, reinforcing their training, protecting their safety, and showering them with love.
The right pet sitter will:
✅ Have experience with young pets
✅ Be calm and consistent
✅ Understand developmental needs
✅ Communicate clearly and often
✅ Treat your pet like their own
Start your search early, ask the right questions, and trust your instincts. You’ll find a sitter who’s not just a helper—but a loving addition to your new pet’s support system.
Affiliate Products
