The Importance of Checking References for Your Pet Sitter

When it comes to trusting someone with your beloved pet, due diligence is non-negotiable.
You’re not just handing over your house keys — you’re entrusting someone with the happiness, health, and safety of a family member.

Checking references is one of the most important stepsyou can take before hiring a pet sitter.
Here’s why it matters so much — and how it helps you make the best possible choice for your pet.

1. References Prove Real Experience

Anyone can create a professional-looking profile or website.
But talking to past clients gives you first-hand proof of their experience.

By checking references, you can find out:

Essentials for Your Newly Adopted Pet

Welcoming a shelter pet into your life is a beautiful journey. Here are some handpicked items to help your new friend feel safe, loved, and right at home:

What types of pets they’ve cared for.
How well they handled different behaviors and personalities.
How consistent and reliable they really were.

Real Talk: A sitter with happy past clients is far more trustworthy than one with only pretty marketing!

2. You Learn About Their Reliability

Was the sitter punctual
Did they follow care instructions precisely
Were they consistent in visiting and communicating

References can reveal if the sitter:

Showed up on time, every time.
Sent updates without being asked.
Went above and beyond basic expectations.

Key: Reliability isn't just about showing up — it's about caring consistently.

3. You Can Spot Red Flags Early

Sometimes a sitter might sound perfect... until you hear from a previous client.

Red flags might include:

Missed appointments or last-minute cancellations.
Poor communication or vague updates.
Careless mistakes with feeding, medication, or exercise routines.
Pets appearing stressed or unkempt upon the owner's return.

Important: Even one bad reference deserves your attention.

4. You Understand Their True Personality

Skills can be taught — but attitude and compassion are harder to fake.

Talking to former clients helps you find out:

Was the sitter patient and loving
Did they bond with the pet
Were they respectful of the home and belongings

Client Insight: A past client’s emotional feedback can tell you more than any resume.

5. It Gives You Peace of Mind

Ultimately, checking references is about protecting your pet — and yourself.

Hearing from real people who have trusted this sitter before gives you:

Confidence that your pet will be safe, happy, and loved.
Reassurance that your home will be respected.
Comfort knowing you’ve made a responsible, informed decision.

Final Truth: Peace of mind is priceless when you’re away from your best friend.

How to Check References Effectively

When you reach out to references, ask specific questions like:

How often did the sitter communicate with you
Did your pet seem happy and well-cared for when you returned
Were there any problems How were they handled
Would you hire this sitter again Why or why not

Pro Tip: Listen not just to what they say, but how they say it — genuine enthusiasm is easy to hear!

Conclusion

Choosing a pet sitter without checking their references is like letting a stranger into your home blindfolded — it’s a risk not worth taking.

Your pet deserves someone who will treat them with love, patience, and responsibility.
By checking references carefully, you can feel confident that you've chosen a sitter who will care for your pet as if they were their own.

Remember: Good sitters expect you to ask questions — and great ones welcome it!

Affiliate Products

We may earn a small commission when you shop through our links — it helps us keep sharing love and care for every dog out there, at no extra cost to you.

View All Products →