Updated on | by Critter Nets - Blogs
How to Hire a Pet Sitter for the First Time
Hiring a pet sitter for the first time can feel nerve-wracking.
You’re not just handing over your house keys — you’re entrusting someone with the care of a beloved family member.
But don’t worry!
With a little planning and a thoughtful approach, you can find a wonderful sitter who will care for your pet as lovingly as you do.
Here’s a step-by-step guide to hiring a pet sitter for the first time — and doing it with confidence.
1. Identify Your Pet's Needs
Before you start looking, think about:
- How often does your pet need care
- Do they have medical needs (medication, special diets)
- Are they shy, energetic, or need extra attention
- Do you prefer someone to stay overnight or just visit
Important: The clearer you are about your pet’s needs, the easier it will be to find the right sitter.
2. Start Your Search Early
Good pet sitters get booked quickly, especially around holidays and vacations.
Where to search:
- Word of Mouth: Ask friends, neighbors, or your vet.
- Online Platforms: Websites like Rover, PetSitter.com, or local pet Facebook groups.
- Professional Associations: Check certified pet sitters through organizations like PSI (Pet Sitters International).
Tip: Start your search at least 2–4 weeks before you need the sitter.
3. Screen Potential Sitters Carefully
Once you have a few names:
- Read reviewsor testimonials.
- Check their experiencewith your type of pet.
- Verify their credentials(are they insured, bonded, or certified).
Pro Tip: Watch for sitters who specialize in your type of pet or have experience with special needs animals.
4. Set Up Interviews
Interview your top candidates either in person or via video call.
Questions to ask:
- What experience do you have with pets like mine
- Are you comfortable administering medications
- What would you do in an emergency
- Can you provide references
Remember: A good sitter expects your questions — and will answer them confidently!
5. Arrange a Meet-and-Greet
Invite the sitter to meet your pet at home before you hire them.
Watch closely:
- Is your pet comfortable around them
- Does the sitter seem confident and loving
- How do they interact — gently, patiently, attentively
Pet Insight: Your pet’s reaction can tell you more than words ever could.
6. Discuss Details Thoroughly
Make sure you cover:
- Feeding routines, medications, and exercise schedules.
- Emergency contacts and your veterinarian’s info.
- House rules (access to certain rooms, handling packages, etc.).
- Payment rates, cancellation policies, and communication expectations.
Bonus Tip: Create a written "pet care manual" to leave for the sitter!
7. Check References
Ask the sitter for at least two references and actually call them.
Questions to ask references:
- Were you happy with their services
- Was your pet well cared for
- Would you hire them again
Golden Rule: Trust what past clients say — they know the sitter best.
8. Do a Trial Run
Before leaving for a long trip, schedule a short test visit or overnight stay.
This lets you:
- Make sure your pet is truly comfortable.
- Confirm the sitter understands your instructions.
- Address any small issues before the full assignment.
Think of it: Like a "dress rehearsal" for the real thing!
Conclusion
Hiring a pet sitter for the first time is a big step — but it doesn’t have to be a stressful one.
By planning ahead, asking the right questions, and trusting both your instincts and your pet’s reactions, you can find a sitter who feels like an extension of your family.
Your pet deserves someone who will treat them with love, patience, and care — just like you do.
Take it step-by-step, trust the process, and soon you’ll be leaving home with peace of mind — and a happy tail-wagging welcome waiting for you when you return!
Affiliate Products
We may earn a small commission when you shop through our links — it helps us keep sharing love and care for every dog out there, at no extra cost to you.
